Hi, I need some help. I have two cats, Samson and Zacheaus. I got them both a little over a year ago, Samson as a kitten and Zacheaus from a foster home. Zacheaus is the main problem. He had a bad kittenhood, I found out that he was locked into his owner's bedroom all day in his first home. He was also declawed at an older age I think. He had two homes before he ended up in the foster home where he didn't get along with the other cats and was eventually locked into a kitchen. When I first got him, there were no problems at all, but I lived in a home without carpet. I had him for three months until I moved back home with my parents and acquired a kitten. He and Samson fell in love and they are like brothers, there was no problem there. But then I went to Germany over spring break and when I got home he was pooping on the carpet every day. My brother supposedly had been scooping out his litter box every day that I was gone. After that point I have had problems with him almost everyday. He's been to the vet twice and nothing is wrong. For a while in the summer he would be good every couple of days because he could go outside but now things are bad again.
Over Christmas I tried an experiment. I scooped out the litter boxes like seven times a day, and for a whole week he didn't poop on the carpet. But i can't keep that up! So thinking he was just extremelly picky, I got him a litter robot. Samson adjusted to it right away.
Zacheaus has been a different story. At first I think he got scared of it because I plugged it in after a few days (I thought maybe he would be better if it was clean all the time). So he continued to poop on the carpet. Then I put back the old litter boxes and covered the LR with a box. He used the litter box for a few days. So I took the litter boxes away and the LR is still covered with the box.
It's been a few days, and I think he is peeing in the LR (but I'm not sure), but he is still pooping on the carpet. And I run the LR like five times a day and make sure Zacheaus doesn't see it happen. I can't handle this! I've been picking poop off of the carpet for a year! I love the cat and don't want to get rid of him because I know no one will take him in, but I'm moving out in a few months to go to grad school and I can't take a cat into an apartment that has this problem.
Should I lock him in a room with the LR to see if he is peeing in it at all? Should I take him to a cat psychologist?
Should I rip up all of the carpet in the room he has been pooping in so that the scent is totally gone?
Should I take the top off the LR and try scooping in out seven times a day again?
Please if anyone has any ideas, I'll try anything! I already spent money on this LR when I have none, and I really want it to work.
Thanks,
Anna

