We don't know if CatMan received a letter yet, he hasn't said. His website is still up.
What I
DO know is that the device is 100% legal, no question. (The device is made within reverse engineering standards and does not violate any trademarks or proprietary designs. Since the cartridges do not use any kind of security, the DMCA is not being violated either.)
In fact, in a previous thread (found here:
http://www.litterbox-central.com/litter-box/catgenie/topic2537-120.html) that was made while people were still in the process of examining the cartridges to see if resetting them was possible, a user was posting his information that helped lead to reprogramming the cartridges. He got nervous and removed his posts on his own. I immediately assumed that it was PetNovations who made him or the board owner remove his posts, and I commented as such:
Pelvis Popcan wrote:It appears PetNovations has strong-armed and bullied members here into removing their posts, despite the fact that they were all within their legal rights and 100% followed the standards of
reverse engineering.
Not cool at all. PetNovations may not like it, but it is completely their fault that they decided not to include
any security features
whatsoever in their cartridge system.
As much as I love my CatGenie, PetNovations as a company has crossed the line, and has completely lost my respect. In fact, their tactics of bullying forum members here might actually be illegal in the USA. This company really has a lot to learn.
I plead to the administrators of the board to
please restore the censored posts.
Within one page, PetNovations responded with the following:
CatGenie wrote:Pelvis, I wish you apologized with as much energy as you attacked us.
I would hope by now, people would see that we are a very honest and straightforward company that would not censor posts. In fact, if you recall Pelvis you wanted posts you made that were not very pleasant about us removed and we said no. Why? Because all of us here at PetNovations not only believe in our product but we also believe in the integrity of our customers words and believe that while we prefer to hear the good, we MUST hear it all--and that is what drives us to never be satisfied and to continue to innovate.
We have and always will stand behind our product. We try and answer tough customer questions and spend time on forums like this one and others to interact with people and never lose our ability to listen. Additionally our dedicated customer service representatives are available by phone 7 days a week, 14 hours each day and we will continue to do so, because we care about our current and future customers. While it may sound hokey, we believe that the CatGenie will one day be THE cat box for everyone. We hope that you support us in this mission and bring cat sanitation into the 21st century.
While I cannot say we support what you are doing, I can say that while cartridge sales are a part of our business model, they are also important to the safe function of the CatGenie. We have already had people try to refill and ruin their floors, gummed up the inside of their unit etc. That is why we sell a cartridge that is sealed with a safe but effective cleaning solution that has been tested to ensure that is not just safe for people, but just as safe for our target user your cat.
We are a start-up company that believes that we have the solution to the litter box and while the CatGenie is far from perfect we do know that it is pretty damn great and will only get better and better. We are only just half way through our 2nd year of business and I personally think our product is pretty amazing and I speak not only as an employee, but also as the longest running CatGenie user in the USA.
We have plenty of things planned that we think will make people want to buy cartridges and that is our goal. We hope you support us not because you have to but because you want to.
Stay tuned!
I don't believe message board posts can be used as evidence, but just in case, I would save the following two pages in case PetNovations is changing their mind on their stance:
http://www.litterbox-central.com/litter-box/catgenie/topic2537-105.htmlhttp://www.litterbox-central.com/litter-box/catgenie/topic2537-120.html